HUGE: Gun Bans on the Brink

Miniature silver pistol lighter beside a yellow warning sign
Photo: Teacher Photo / Shutterstock

A Supreme Court justice just told Maryland its gun-free zones might not survive the next legal fight, even while the Court let them stand today.

Quick Take

  • The Supreme Court refused to hear a challenge to Maryland’s broad “sensitive places” gun law, leaving it in force for now.
  • Justice Clarence Thomas wrote separately, saying he “harbor[s] serious doubts” the restrictions match America’s historical gun-law tradition.
  • Thomas said a future, narrower case should test how far states can go in banning guns from public places.
  • Maryland’s law covers government buildings, schools, parks, transit, stadiums, museums, casinos, hospitals, and bars.

What The Court Actually Decided Monday

The Supreme Court denied review in Novotny v. Moore on November 16, 2026, closing the door on this particular case. That means the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruling upholding nearly all of Maryland’s restrictions stays in place. No justice issued a majority opinion striking anything down. The practical result favors Maryland for now, even though the legal argument against the law got a surprisingly loud airing from one justice.

Justice Thomas didn’t dissent from the denial outright. Instead he wrote a statement explaining why he still voted no. He said the sheer size of the challenge, covering a dozen-plus categories of locations at once, made it a messy vehicle for the Supreme Court to use. Courts prefer clean, narrow questions. Maryland’s challengers brought a sprawling one, and Thomas said that breadth complicated review rather than making the case easier to decide.

Why Thomas Still Sounded Alarmed

Despite voting to deny the case, Thomas didn’t pull punches on the merits. He wrote that he doubts “our Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation supports many of these sweeping restrictions”. That’s a notable line from a sitting justice on a case the Court just refused to touch. It reads like an invitation, not a dismissal, and gun-rights advocates online treated it exactly that way within hours of the order.

Thomas went further, specifically asking for a future case. He wrote that “in an appropriate and more narrowly focused case,” the Court “should consider the scope of States’ authority to ban firearms in ‘sensitive places'”. That’s a roadmap. Lawyers challenging similar laws in other states now have a sitting justice on record saying he wants to take this up, just not this version of it.

Maryland’s Defense Rests On History Too

Maryland didn’t just claim public safety justified the law, though Governor Wes Moore made that case plainly, calling the ruling “a major win for public safety”. Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown built his legal defense on the same historical test Thomas uses. Brown argued there’s a “rich American tradition” of barring guns in confined, crowded spaces, pointing to old bans at polling places, courthouses, and legislative halls as proof the list of sensitive places was never meant to be short.

Brown’s brief leaned hard on crowding and vulnerability as the historical thread tying everything together. Bars, mass transit, and amusement venues got grouped as crowded spaces with old analogues. Hospitals and museums got defended as places with vulnerable populations nearby. Whether old liquor-house laws really justify banning carry at a modern stadium is exactly the kind of question Thomas wants a future Court to dig into, location by location.

The Legal Fight Nobody Expects To End Here

This case sits inside a bigger argument that’s been running since the Supreme Court’s 2022 Bruen decision, which said gun laws must match historical tradition, not just serve a good government reason. States responded to Bruen by writing long lists of restricted locations. Gun-rights groups responded by suing almost immediately, arguing legislatures turned a narrow carve-out into a geographic ban covering huge chunks of daily life.

The Fourth Circuit sided with Maryland on all but one location, accepting the state’s historical analogues as close enough. That outcome now stands as the operating law in Maryland and a reference point other circuits may lean on. Until someone brings Thomas the narrow, single-category case he’s asking for, his skepticism remains a signal flare rather than a ruling, and permit holders in Maryland still have to navigate the same long list of off-limits places.

Expect the next challenge to look very different. A lawsuit targeting just transit stations, or just state parks, with a tight historical record attached, stands a far better shot at a full hearing than another everything-at-once petition. Thomas basically wrote the opening brief for whoever files it next.

Sources:

cbsnews.com, scotusblog.com, governor.maryland.gov, supremecourt.gov, publications.lawschool.cornell.edu, firearmslaw.duke.edu