
An Arizona man now sits in jail accused of planning to bomb a house of worship, then have a gunman shoot down the people who ran for their lives.
Quick Take
- Matthew Bjornholt faces one count of making a terroristic threat in Maricopa County, Arizona.
- Prosecutors say he described bombing one worship site to pull people toward a second bomb, then having an accomplice shoot survivors as they fled.
- A home search turned up three firearms and a copy of The Anarchist Cookbook, which he allegedly called his “Bible.”
- His defense attorney calls the case fabricated hearsay and says federal agents reviewed his phones and let him go.
- A judge found probable cause anyway, setting a $100,000 bond with electronic monitoring and a weapons ban.
What Prosecutors Say He Planned
Court documents summarized by Arizona news outlets describe a chilling two-step plan. Bjornholt allegedly said he would plant a bomb at one place of worship to pull attention away from a bigger bomb at a nearby site. An accomplice would then wait outside and start “picking off people” as they ran from the blasts, according to prosecutors. The alleged targets were Jewish or Muslim institutions in Maricopa County, though the exact locations have not been made public.
A reported witness, described as a former friend, allegedly brought the claims to authorities. That tip set off a state investigation that led to Bjornholt’s arrest on a single terroristic-threat charge. The charge itself is narrower than the attack prosecutors describe in court filings, reflecting what law enforcement says it can currently prove, not a completed bombing or conspiracy conviction.
Guns, a Bomb Manual, and a Judge’s Decision
Investigators searched Bjornholt’s home and found three firearms along with a copy of The Anarchist Cookbook, a book long associated with homemade explosive instructions and tied in public memory to the Oklahoma City bombing. Prosecutors told the court he called the book his “Bible.” No bomb-making materials, like chemicals or devices, were reportedly recovered during that search.
A Maricopa County judge reviewed the evidence and found it sufficient to establish probable cause, letting the case move forward. The judge set a $100,000 secured bond and ordered electronic monitoring, a ban on weapons, and no contact with witnesses or alleged victims. Those conditions suggest the court took the allegations seriously even at this early stage.
The Defense Says the Whole Thing Is Hearsay
Bjornholt’s attorney, Chad Shell, flatly denies the accusations. “He never made any of these terroristic statements at any time to anybody,” Shell said. “It’s all made up.” He argues the entire case rests on claims from a man Bjornholt had kicked out of his house just two days before the alleged statements surfaced, not on any recording, device, or written plan.
Shell also points to what federal investigators did not find. He says Bjornholt voluntarily handed over his phone passwords, and agents searched every device without turning up anything related to terrorism. He adds that the three guns were legally owned, with no more than twenty rounds of ammunition for each one, standard magazine capacity and nothing more.
Why the FBI Walked Away From the Case
Here is where the story gets harder to square. The Federal Bureau of Investigation reviewed Bjornholt’s devices and ultimately declined to file federal charges, according to reporting on the case. Maricopa County prosecutors moved forward anyway with a state charge. No public explanation has been given for why federal investigators passed while county prosecutors saw enough to proceed, leaving a real gap between the two agencies’ conclusions.
That gap matters. Research on federal terrorism prosecutions since the September 11, 2001 attacks shows a sharp shift toward stopping alleged plots before they happen, with prevented cases rising from 29 percent of indictments before 9/11 to 60 percent in the years after. That approach catches real threats early, but it can also mean cases built on an alleged plan rather than a finished act, which is exactly why courts weigh probable cause so carefully before trial.
A Case That Still Has to Be Proven
CAIR-Arizona publicly welcomed the state charge and pushed for federal prosecutors to follow suit, framing the allegations as a mass-casualty plot against religious communities. That reaction is understandable given the stakes described in the charging documents. But an arrest is an allegation, not a conviction, and this case will now move through pretrial hearings where prosecutors must back up their claims with more than one witness’s account.
What happens next depends on evidence neither side has fully shown the public yet. Did Bjornholt scout any specific building? Did an accomplice ever exist? Those answers will come out in discovery, not headlines. Until then, the case stands as a serious accusation resting on a single charge, a judge’s probable-cause finding, and a defense attorney calling the whole thing invented.
Sources:
nypost.com, azfamily.com, azcentral.com, tucson.com, yahoo.com














